Big Finish reached a milestone when they released their 150th Main Range release ‘Recorded Time and Other Stories’. In the 12 years since they were licensed to produce Doctor Who stories. Over the 150 releases the stories have varied quite a lot. Colin Baker, Peter Davison and Sylvester McCoy were there at the very beginning and Paul McGann joined in 2001. We have also been reintroduced to classic companions with only Matthew Waterhouse not coming back as Adric (though have we really missed him?). But we have also been introduced to new companions and that is what has made these adventures more than just Doctor Who on audio. These are new companions that we have seen from the start. I only started watching Doctor Who properly in 1993 so until the show returned in 2005, the Big Finish companions were the only ‘new’ characters that I have seen in their debut stories.
The format of these stories has changed over the years. From 1999 to 2007, the stories would be released in random order with a Fifth Doctor story being released one month and then a Seventh Doctor story being released the next month. Then after Nicholas Briggs took over as the executive producer of the main range we started to get ‘three + one’ releases. They didn’t really work because very often the three episodes would be great as they cut out all the padding that accompanies a normal four part adventure but very often the single part story would let the whole release down. It has taken me a while for BF to get a handle on these single episodes. But it was in 2008 when the format of the main range releases would change. Due to a story arc involving the Fifth Doctor, Nyssa and Thomas Brewster, it was decided that starting in 2009 there would series of stories that would be released one after another. So there would be three series of three adventures with a single release. With the Eighth Doctor having adventures in his own series, it would be Doctors 5,6 & 7 that would get their own series of adventures.
During these 150 stories we have seen some classic monsters return via BF. These include the Daleks, Cybermen and the Master which were obvious ones but it some of the lesser popular monsters that have returned. They included The Axons (Feast of Axos – 2011), Omega (Omega – 2003), Ice Warriors (Red Dawn – 2003 and Frozen Time – 2008), Rutan (Castle of Fear – 2009) and The Mara (Cradle of the Snake – 2010). It’s always a curious decision to bring back monsters that only appeared once or maybe twice in the classic era but usually its with good intentions and whilst I may not have been wholly positive about a story (Robophobia) I am always open to them bringing back monsters that only made a single appearance as long as it is justified.
The big names that have appeared in these 150 stories over the years has also been impressive. Names such as David Walliams (Little Britain and swimming the Thames), Mark Gatiss (League of Gentleman), Joe Thomas (Inbetweeners), Anna Masey (Peeping Tom) to name but a few. It’s always surprising to see the sort of people that will appear in audio Who as opposed to TV Who. To appear on TV Doctor Who I could understand because of the exposure it would give them but I think that the fact their in a Doctor Who is more of a personal thing than a professional thing.
The stories that have been done over the last 11 years have used a large number of writers. Some had written for the TV series and some would go onto write for the new series. In fact the 2002 story Spare Parts was inspiration for the 2006 David Tennant stories ‘Rise of the Cybermen/The Age of Steel’ and in 2005 Robert Shearman adapted his 2003 adventure ‘Jubilee’ to become ‘Dalek. Due to the contract that BF has with the BBC it means that BF can’t use a monster or villain or even story if it mirrors one that is being used on TV. That’s why in the 2009 Lost Story ‘The Hollows of Time’ the Master wasn’t used as he was appearing on TV. It seems that this only really becomes a problem when they want to use a classic villain/monster, otherwise they are free to do whatever they want and the only restriction is really on what they want to do. There have been tendencies when the story has been complicated. The most obvious example of this was in the 2008 adventure ‘Brotherhood of the Daleks’ which is quite possibly the most complicated story that BF have done. Even Colin Baker wasn’t fully aware of what was going on. Most of the time it’s just me that doesn’t understand what’s going on but on some rare occasions like BOTD, it’s a group thing.
I decided to do a massive poll to decide what was the most popular Big Finish story in the main range. I suspected that ‘The Chimes of Midnight’ would have a good chance because it won the Toms Tardis ‘Story of the Decade’ award in 2009. If you didn’t vote then the way then let me explain how it worked. Basically I opened the poll so that you could select your 10 favourite stories. Not just one because I know how difficult that can be but 10.
Here is what I voted for in this poll.
1 – Live 34 (2005) 9 – The Chimes of Midnight (2002)
2 – Project: Twilight (2001) 10 – Medicinal Purposes (2004)
3 – Project: Lazarus (2003)
4 – Son of the Dragon (2007)
5 – Nocturne (2007)
6 – Enemy of the Daleks (2009)
7 – The Reaping (2006)
8 – The Nowhere Place (2006)
After all the votes had been counted the (not surprising) winner was the 2002 adventure ‘The Chimes of Midnight’. It got 51 votes, second was another 2002 adventure ‘Spare Parts’ which got 43 and quite surprisingly ‘The One Doctor’ from 2001 was the third most popular story with 38 votes. Now it is an enjoyable story but I don’t think that its one of the top 3 stories ever.
Winners of the Best Story category in the Toms Tardis Stories did as follows;
1999 – Phantasmagoria #42 with 5 votes
2000 – The Marian Conspiracy #8 with 29 votes
2001 – Project: Twilight #22 with 10 votes
2002 – The Chimes of Midnight #1 with 51 votes
2003 – Doctor Who and the Pirates #7 with 30 votes
2004 – The Harvest #27 with 8 votes
2005 – The Juggernauts #49 with 4 votes
2006 – Pier Pressure #84 with 2 votes
2007 – Son of the Dragon #22 with 10 votes
2008 – The Haunting of Thomas Brewster #36 with 6 votes
2009 – The Magic Mousetrap #36 with 6 votes
2010 – The Wreck of the Titan #6 with 32 votes
Out of 150 stories, there were only 16 stories that didn’t get a single vote. They were Minuet in Hell (2001), The Rapture (2002), The Sandman (2002), Nekromanteia (2003), The Creed of the Kromon (2004), The Roof of the World (2004), The Last (2004), The Game (2005), Three’s A Crowd (2005), Red (2006), Valhalla (2007), The Wishing Beast/The Vanity Box (2007), The Dark Husband (2008), The Chaos Pool (2009), Lurkers at Sunlight’s Edge (2010), Recorded Time and Other Stories (2011).
Some of these I kind of understand, I’m not wild about Minuet in Hell, Red, Valhalla or Nekromanteia but then there are some that I think should have at least got a vote such as The Game which has William Russell in it. I also thought that Recorded Time and Other Stories and Lurkers at Sunlight’s Edge should have received a vote. How something like …ish (111th with 1 vote) or Renaissance of the Daleks (60th with 3 votes) managed to score higher I will never know.
Big Finish have achieved a lot in 150 stories, they have used new and old monsters in these stories and also bought some popular combinations back. 2012 looks like being another good year with Tom Baker joining the Big Finish family but when/if we do a poll for the Best 200 stories I suspect that ‘The Chimes of Midnight’ will win. Congratulations to Big Finish, you were there when Doctor Who was on TV and you show that you can produce stories just as good as the ones on TV with a fraction of their budget.
To use a cricket term to describe my feelings about Big Finish -150 not out
